When Every Dollar Goes Toward Winning, What’s Left for Tomorrow?

A college athletics program can generate record revenue, receive more institutional support than ever, and still be more financially vulnerable than it was five years ago.

How?

Because more money doesn’t necessarily translate into greater financial flexibility. Especially when it’s already committed to future expenses.

Conference distributions increase, commercial opportunities expand, and governing boards authorize additional institutional investment. But much of that new funding is quickly committed to rosters and other competitive priorities. Often, that’s intentional. But as commitments grow, so does the financial exposure.

What happens if the money we’re counting on doesn’t materialize, or the people responsible for providing it change their minds?

Don’t count on the spending competition slowing down

It’s tempting to believe college athletics’ financial pressures will stabilize once the regulatory dust settles.

I’m not convinced.

The House settlement capped institutional revenue sharing, but it didn’t cap the cost of competing. The Big Ten has adopted a framework allowing up to $49 million in institutionally arranged athlete compensation, including direct revenue sharing and certain third-party NIL arrangements. The SEC is considering a luxury tax model with spending thresholds exceeding $70 million.

Whatever restrictions ultimately take hold, don’t expect institutions to voluntarily surrender a competitive advantage. Athletes and coaches aren’t lining up to take pay cuts, and programs with the greatest resources to invest aggressively aren’t suddenly going to accept falling behind.

Operating on the hope that future rules will solve today’s financial challenges isn’t a business strategy.

Neither is assuming new revenue or institutional support will keep pace with rising commitments. The spending competition isn’t going away. So, college athletics needs to figure out how to build the financial capacity to sustain it.

English football’s billion-dollar lesson for college athletics

England’s Premier League has become one of the most commercially successful sports leagues in the world. But record revenues haven’t necessarily translated into financial stability. The fear of relegation fuels aggressive spending on talent, with many clubs relying on wealthy owners to fund operating losses.

Sound familiar?

England’s newly established Independent Football Regulator recently proposed risk-based liquidity requirements, recognizing that clubs face different financial exposures and need time to build financial reserves. The regulator’s own research found that 66% of surveyed clubs couldn’t survive more than 90 days without additional owner funding. Lower-tier clubs would need reserves covering at least one month’s wages, with higher-risk clubs also required to cover up to five months of operating losses. Premier League clubs would be assessed individually, and clubs would have until 2030 to build toward the requirements.

The financial risks vary considerably across English football. Premier League clubs compete to protect lucrative broadcasting revenues, while lower-tier clubs invest aggressively in hopes of promotion. Relegation can mean a significant revenue decline without an equivalent reduction in expenses.

College athletics has a different business model, but the parallels are difficult to ignore. While we don’t have promotion and relegation, there are vastly different realities across Division I, with conference realignment widening the divide. And like English football, growing revenues and institutional investments are often quickly committed to remaining competitive, with universities increasingly serving as the financial backstop.

Access to someone else’s money shouldn’t be mistaken for financial resilience.

College athletics may not need a regulator or mandatory cash reserves. But the English approach offers a useful lesson: Start by understanding the financial exposure, develop a plan to address it, and recognize that building resilience takes time.

For college athletics, that means liquidity planning.

A balanced budget doesn’t necessarily mean cash will be available when obligations come due. Liquidity planning looks beyond annual revenues and expenses to anticipate cash needs, identify available funding, and prepare for shortfalls.

For athletics, that means accounting for the timing of conference distributions, sponsorships (what’s left of them anyway), donor contributions, institutional support, roster investments, coaching buyouts, and debt service. A donor pledge isn’t cash in the bank, restricted funds aren’t necessarily available for operations, and future institutional support isn’t guaranteed.

The path to financial flexibility looks different across Division I.

Power 4: Is institutional support a strategy or an assumption?

For some Power 4 programs, increased institutional support is a deliberate investment in athletics’ brand value and competitiveness. For others, it’s become necessary to close the gap between revenue and spending commitments.

Either way, today’s commitments may depend on funding that isn’t guaranteed tomorrow. Changes in university leadership, governing boards, or state politics can shift priorities long before multi-year obligations expire.

Ask yourself: is institutional support part of a long-term financial strategy, or simply a commitment to cover annual shortfalls?

Athletics leadership, governing boards, and university finance need a shared understanding of the answer. A financial model should connect roster spending, revenue growth, institutional support, and cash flow, including what happens when expectations aren’t met.

The rest of Division I: Building strength without the same financial firepower

Outside the Power 4, programs face similar competitive pressures without comparable revenue growth. Many rely heavily on institutional support, student fees, and philanthropy, making funding predictability as important as revenue generation.

Substantial cash reserves may be unrealistic, but understanding recurring funding, aligning cash inflows with obligations, and establishing contingency plans can provide greater financial flexibility.

New commercial opportunities can help, but concerts, sponsorships, and premium experiences also require upfront investment and ongoing expenses. More revenue doesn’t necessarily mean more liquidity, especially when every additional dollar is immediately committed elsewhere.

For these programs, financial resilience may depend less on accumulating reserves and more on securing reliable funding and maintaining the flexibility to adjust when circumstances change.

Could a NewCo create an entirely different opportunity?

Imagine a NewCo with a defined level of institutional support and a successful commercial strategy generating cash beyond its operating needs. The temptation may be to immediately reinvest that surplus in rosters. But what if the institution moderated spending growth and retained earnings to build liquidity reserves or, eventually, an investment portfolio capable of generating income for future operations?

Of course, a NewCo doesn’t automatically create financial flexibility. Its structure, funding arrangements, governance, and tax considerations all matter. But a financially successful NewCo could do more than generate additional spending capacity. It could create the capacity to accumulate and invest earnings over time.

And that introduces an interesting competitive possibility. What if retaining some earnings today creates the capacity to make investments competitors can’t afford tomorrow?

Financial resilience won’t happen overnight, and liquidity planning isn’t a one-size-fits-all model. Better forecasting alone won’t fix a business model that consistently requires more funding than it generates, but it gives leadership the information needed to make decisions intentionally rather than reactively. Whether the goal is improving cash flow visibility, securing more predictable funding, or building long-term reserves, the first step is moving from reacting to financial pressures to planning for them.

Building financial flexibility starts with understanding where you stand today and what’s possible tomorrow. James Moore’s Collegiate Athletics CPAs and consultants work with athletic departments and affiliated entities to evaluate financial risks, strengthen financial planning, and develop practical roadmaps toward long-term sustainability.

All content provided in this article is for informational purposes only. Matters discussed in this article are subject to change. For up-to-date information on this subject please contact a James Moore professional. James Moore will not be held responsible for any claim, loss, damage or inconvenience caused as a result of any information within these pages or any information accessed through this site.