When Foundation Partnerships Outgrow Their Governance

A college or university is facing a budget shortfall and looks to its foundation for help. The foundation has substantial assets, a successful fundraising program and a board that’s committed to the institution’s success.

So why can’t the foundation just write the check?

Usually the answer comes down to donor restrictions and commitments the foundation has already made, along with its responsibility to preserve resources for future years. I covered those limits in more detail in Your Foundation Has Millions in Assets. How Much Can It Actually Spend? Both organizations generally understand them on their own. What they often don’t have is a shared financial picture that lets them work through the options together.

We see this tension regularly in our work with college and university foundations. The institution’s funding needs are real, and the foundation wants to help. But the foundation also has to protect what donors restricted and what future years depend on, and keeping both organizations pointed at the same strategic objectives takes more than agreeing on priorities.

I think this is becoming a more important issue as institutions face growing financial pressure and foundations are asked to play a larger role in institutional financial strategy.

In an October 2026 NACUBO In Brief podcast on higher education governance, leaders from the Association of Governing Boards talked about how governing boards, institutional leaders, foundations and business officers can work together as strategic partners. That closer partnership makes sense. But as the foundation’s role expands, governance and financial oversight need to keep pace with it.

Strategic alignment doesn’t eliminate financial risk

Institution and foundation leadership can agree completely on priorities and still have very different understandings of the financial commitments it takes to support them.

Consider a university launching a new academic program or opening a satellite campus with philanthropic support. The foundation secures multi-year pledges to help fund construction and program development, and the university starts hiring faculty and making other long-term commitments.

The initiative is strategically sound. But two years later, construction costs have run over budget, pledge collections are behind schedule and operating costs are higher than planned. Meanwhile, the university is dealing with financial pressures of its own.

The university expects the foundation to help close the gap. The foundation has already committed what it had available for the initiative, and its remaining assets are restricted for other purposes. What started as a shared priority can quickly become a source of tension between the two leadership teams.

The consequences go beyond the immediate shortfall. The university might have to redirect operating dollars or take on additional debt. The foundation might feel pressure to accelerate distributions or pull unrestricted resources away from other priorities.

The risk is compounded when each organization looks at its obligations on its own. The foundation approves funding based on anticipated pledge collections or investment distributions, and the university builds that support into its capital and operating budgets. Without coordinated planning, it’s likely that neither side sees the combined exposure, or how a change in one organization’s assumptions affects the other.

Are boards getting the complete financial picture?

These situations also raise a harder governance question. Institution and foundation boards have distinct fiduciary responsibilities. Trustees are responsible for the institution’s financial sustainability, and foundation directors are responsible for stewarding assets in line with donor restrictions and the foundation’s charitable purpose. Neither board should have to give up its independence because their financial interests intersect. And in some cases, nobody from the institution’s governing board sits on the foundation board, which makes formal coordination and information sharing that much more important.

Good governance here means clear expectations for sharing financial information and for escalating decisions when commitments or risks cross from one organization to the other, while each board keeps its own oversight role.

For significant joint initiatives, I’d encourage both organizations to agree in advance on funding assumptions, contingency plans and the circumstances that would bring the boards back in. Foundation boards need enough visibility into the institution’s financial condition and project obligations to weigh a request for more support. Trustees, in turn, need a realistic picture of what the foundation actually has available after existing commitments and restrictions.

That coordination shouldn’t stop after the initial approvals. A project that was financially viable when it was approved can look very different after cost overruns or delayed gift collections. Periodic reporting to both organizations on project costs and remaining funding, along with an agreed process for dealing with material changes, helps address issues before they turn into larger financial problems.

An MOU is only part of the governance framework

The memorandum of understanding between an institution and its foundation is an important document. It sets out each organization’s responsibilities and the framework for the relationship. CASE is also addressing these relationships in a webinar.

As these partnerships take on more financial weight, an MOU review is a good time to ask whether the documented responsibilities still match how the two organizations actually operate. The MOU sets expectations, but financial processes, internal controls and reporting practices are what make them work. Decision-making authority, cost allocations and reporting expectations should hold up in practice, especially when circumstances change after the initial approvals.

As foundations take on a bigger role in institutional financial strategy, I think the real opportunity is to coordinate the financial decisions behind shared priorities, in addition to the priorities themselves. That means bringing both perspectives to the table before commitments are made. James Moore’s Higher Education CPAs and consultants work with colleges, universities and their affiliated foundations on financial reporting, governance practices and operating arrangements, helping leadership find gaps in financial oversight and strengthen coordination between the organizations.

All content provided in this article is for informational purposes only. Matters discussed in this article are subject to change. For up-to-date information on this subject please contact a James Moore professional. James Moore will not be held responsible for any claim, loss, damage or inconvenience caused as a result of any information within these pages or any information accessed through this site.