Turning Suspicion Into Strategy
Building a compensation structure that's competitive, equitable, and built to hold up
We could tell you about compensation market reviews… or you can read how we helped a municipality turn pay guesswork into strategy.
Challenge
Municipal employers compete for talent against private-sector pay scales while managing tight budgets and climbing state minimum wages. When a compensation structure hasn't been reviewed in years, the gaps show up as turnover in hard-to-fill roles, internal inequity between employees doing similar work, and compliance exposure that arrives on a fixed calendar date.
A Florida municipality suspected its pay had drifted from the market but had no data to support that suspicion—and no defensible basis for making adjustments to elected officials or staff. A closer look revealed the scope of the problem: 20% of employees were earning below the September 2026 minimum wage threshold, creating a hard deadline for changes. Four supervisory roles needed FLSA classification review. The public safety pay structure applied uniform wages regardless of tenure, limiting the ability to reward experience and retain skilled employees. Across the organization, pay levels had fallen out of step with industry standards, but without documentation, leadership couldn't quantify where or by how much. Even more complex: job titles didn't always match the work, meaning some pay disparity was a job architecture problem, not just a compensation problem.
Solutions
James Moore's HR Solutions team conducted a structured five-part Compensation Market Review built on the municipality's own data and validated against external market benchmarks. The process paired internal compensation data, job descriptions, and organizational structure against comparable municipality benchmarks and external market resources—creating defensible findings, not guesses.
Our team tested role classifications against FLSA guidelines and measured current pay against the upcoming minimum wage threshold, surfacing the municipality's most time-sensitive exposure. They identified which roles required deeper review before salary changes were finalized, ensuring pay adjustments didn't mask underlying job description problems.
The outcome was a rebuilt pay grade structure with a starting rate aligned to Florida's 2026 minimum wage increase of $15.00 per hour. Each grade spanned 40% from minimum to maximum—providing flexibility based on experience and role complexity while creating clear progression paths. For public safety roles previously paid uniformly, this structure created room to recognize tenure without forcing a promotion every time someone earned a raise. The municipality also received a prioritized roadmap: address minimum wage exposure, review supervisory classifications, adopt the new structure, validate job titles, and monitor market trends over time.
Results
Our compensation analysis quantified what the municipality had only suspected:
- 64% of employees were underpaid compared to industry standards and job requirements
- 26% were appropriately compensated and aligned with market benchmarks
- 10% were overpaid, indicating salary allocation inefficiencies
The municipality gained more than numbers. By bringing in our expertise in market benchmarking, compliance strategy, and job architecture alignment, we gave them a documented, defensible basis for pay decisions—a structure built to absorb minimum wage increases without collapsing, and a way to reward experienced employees they couldn't afford to lose. Their compensation program now supports compliance, retention, internal equity, and long-term workforce stability, with a clear roadmap they could execute on their own timeline.
Be the First to Hear.
Sign up for our newsletter and have it delivered to your inbox, so you don’t miss a thing.