Why Leverage Is No Longer Just a Return Enhancer in Today’s Real Estate Market

In today’s real estate market, your real estate leverage strategy may be your biggest risk factor, not your biggest advantage. What worked two years ago is quietly working against investors in 2026, and the ones who haven’t adjusted are feeling it.

During a recent Your CPA’s Take on Real Estate episode, Kyle Paxton shared candid insight on why the classic leverage playbook is breaking down and what investors need to rethink before entering their next deal.

The Old Playbook No Longer Applies

For years, the formula was simple. Generate equity, take on heavy leverage, collect strong returns, and repeat. Debt was cheap, asset values were climbing, and the market was forgiving enough that even aggressive assumptions often worked out.

That environment is gone.

“Debt was cheap, asset values are rising,” Kyle noted. “But now we’re seeing in a lot of ways leverage is just amplifying the problems that are your foundational problems.”

The issue isn’t that leverage has changed. It’s that the market conditions that made heavy leverage safe have changed. Rent growth has slowed, especially in high-supply Sunbelt markets. Expenses have continued to climb. Insurance and property taxes in states like Florida are creating additional pressure. And the income side of deals simply isn’t growing fast enough to keep pace.

When all of those factors tighten at the same time, leverage stops being a tool that amplifies your gains. It becomes a tool that amplifies your problems.

What Higher Rates Actually Do to Deal Math

Interest rates sit at the center of this shift. Kyle broke it down directly.

“Higher rates just reduce cash flow. More of your property’s income is going to the lender.”

That’s the straightforward version. But the downstream effects go further. Higher rates reduce the loan proceeds available to a buyer, which means buyers either need to bring more equity to the table or accept a lower purchase price to hit the same return targets. The same net operating income that supported a highly leveraged deal a few years ago now supports significantly less debt.

“The same NOI in the current market supports much less debt,” Kyle said.

For investors who bought using low rate assumptions, cheap refinancing expectations and projections of strong rent growth, the math has quietly shifted underneath them. Deals that looked healthy on paper are now squeezed from multiple directions at once.

Leverage as a Risk Decision, Not a Return Decision

Kyle’s core reframe is worth sitting with. Leverage shouldn’t be evaluated primarily through the lens of return enhancement. In this market, it needs to be evaluated as a risk-management decision.

“When you have too much debt, you’re taking that good property, a good asset you have, and by itself turning it into a bad investment.”

That’s a meaningful distinction. A fundamentally sound asset can become a poor investment simply because of how it’s capitalized. The property hasn’t changed. The debt structure made it fragile.

This is especially relevant for investors still entering deals with optimistic refinance or exit assumptions. Kyle flagged this as one of the most common underwriting mistakes he’s seeing right now. The lending process is slower, more scrutinizing and less flexible than it was a few years ago. Relying on a smooth refinance or a clean exit at the right cap rate is a riskier bet than it looks.

What Cautious Leverage Actually Looks Like

Pulling back on leverage doesn’t mean avoiding deals. Kyle is clear that good deals still exist in 2026. But they look different.

The deals that are working share a few traits. They’re grounded in basis discipline. They have strong current cash flow rather than depending on future rent growth. The debt is more conservative. And the exit assumptions are realistic, not optimistic.

“There are pockets of motivated sellers, broken capital stacks, assumable debts, properties that are operating inefficiently,” Kyle said. “If a buyer has a specific advantage or niche or the additional capital, there is opportunity out there.”

The investors finding those opportunities are the ones who have adjusted their risk thinking, not just their return targets. They’re not avoiding leverage entirely. They’re being deliberate about how much they take on and why.

Rethinking Your Approach Before the Next Deal

Real estate leverage strategy in 2026 isn’t about using less debt for the sake of it. It’s about recognizing that the market is less forgiving than it was and that the cushion investors used to rely on, through quick rent growth, compressed cap rates and easy refinancing, is no longer there to absorb mistakes.

The investors who are scaling right now aren’t the ones with the most aggressive capital stacks. They’re the ones who understand their risk exposure clearly and are building deals that can survive a less cooperative market.

Watch the full episode with Kyle Paxton to hear his complete breakdown of what’s changed, where opportunities still exist and how to think about underwriting in today’s environment.

All content provided in this article is for informational purposes only. Matters discussed in this article are subject to change. For up-to-date information on this subject please contact a James Moore professional. James Moore will not be held responsible for any claim, loss, damage or inconvenience caused as a result of any information within these pages or any information accessed through this site.