Florida’s New Clear to Care Act Mandates Criminal Background Checks for Physician Renewal

Florida Expands Background Check Requirements to All Licensed Physicians

Florida healthcare organizations face new compliance challenges following the implementation of HB 975, also known as the Clear to Care Act, which took effect July 1, 2024. The legislation mandates criminal background checks and fingerprinting for all healthcare professionals applying for initial licenses or renewing existing licenses, including physicians with decades of practice experience.

Previously, only certain healthcare professionals, including allopathic and osteopathic physicians, interns and fellows, physician assistants, and various nursing professionals, were required to undergo background screening for licensure. The new law significantly expands these requirements to include dentists, pharmacists, physical therapists, psychologists, acupuncturists and other allied providers who had not been subject to prior background screening.

Physician Pushback and Concerns About Professional Retention

The legislation has generated significant resistance from practicing physicians, with some calling the requirements unconstitutional and humiliating. A dermatologist with nearly 30 years of Florida practice expressed plans to let their license lapse rather than comply with the fingerprinting requirement, citing constitutional concerns about unreasonable search and seizure without probable cause.

Republican Representative Joel Rudman, a family medicine physician in the Florida Panhandle, described the fingerprinting process as humiliating during committee discussions, stating it was the most embarrassing experience he had encountered as a medical doctor. Rudman was the only legislator to vote against the bipartisan bill during committee review.

Financial and Operational Impact on Healthcare Organizations

Healthcare organizations must now factor additional administrative costs and processing time into their credentialing and renewal procedures. The background check requirement applies to both new licensees and renewal applicants, potentially creating bottlenecks in staffing decisions and physician recruitment efforts.

Organizations that rely on federal Medicare and Medicaid programs already face significant penalties for hiring sanctioned physicians, including fines up to $10,000 per violation and potential suspension from federal healthcare programs. The new state requirements add another layer of compliance complexity to an already regulated environment.

Potential Workforce Implications in Context of Physician Shortages

The policy change arrives at a time when Florida faces documented physician shortages, with patients experiencing delays in accessing timely care. Statistical analysis shows that approximately three-tenths of one percent of physicians in the United States have been charged with crimes covered by the legislation, raising questions about the cost-effectiveness of universal screening.

Some physicians have expressed intent to relocate their practice to states without similar requirements, potentially exacerbating existing workforce challenges. The long-term impact on physician recruitment and retention remains unclear as the policy implementation continues.

Regulatory Compliance Considerations for Healthcare Employers

Healthcare facilities must now integrate expanded background screening into their existing credentialing processes. These requirements supplement existing federal exclusion checks, healthcare sanctions reviews, and other compliance measures already mandated for organizations participating in government healthcare programs.

The fingerprinting process involves coordination with state agencies and may result in processing delays if print quality issues occur, particularly for older applicants or those with certain work histories that affect fingerprint clarity. Organizations should plan for potential delays in licensing timelines and associated staffing implications.

Healthcare organizations navigating these new background check requirements can benefit from specialized guidance. Contact James Moore’s healthcare practice team to discuss how these developments may impact your organization.

All content provided in this article is for informational purposes only. Matters discussed in this article are subject to change. For up-to-date information on this subject please contact a James Moore professional. James Moore will not be held responsible for any claim, loss, damage or inconvenience caused as a result of any information within these pages or any information accessed through this site.