Telling Your Financial Story: How Athletics CFOs Can Proactively Drive Action

In collegiate athletics, the chief financial officer often serves as both recordkeeper and strategic translator. Athletic directors, presidents, and trustees look to CFOs not only to explain what happened, but to forecast what’s next and frame what should happen.

The challenge? Financial data is complex, and senior leaders are stretched thin. To cut through the noise, CFOs must translate financial data into clear, actionable insight, moving beyond historical reporting to deliver forward-focused insights that drive decisions.

Here are five ways to communicate financial information that truly moves leadership to action.

1. Lead with the “So What”

Start every conversation with impact, not inputs. Instead of opening with raw figures, begin with what those numbers mean for the institution’s mission, competitiveness, sustainability or whatever else is most important to your audience.

Then take it one step further and offer insight. Instead of stopping at, “Travel costs increased 7%,” continue with, “If this trend continues, we’ll need to adjust non-conference scheduling or renegotiate travel contracts by spring.”

Proactive tips:

• Include leading indicators (like donor pipeline or recruiting travel spend) alongside historicals.
• End each report section with a forward-looking statement: “If X continues, we recommend Y.”
• Frame issues around decision windows (what leadership can act on now to change future outcomes).

2. Tailor the Message and Frame Tradeoffs

Different leaders have different time horizons and priorities. Go beyond customizing what data you show by tailoring how you frame decisions.

Proactive tips:

• For the president: Highlight long-term tradeoffs. “We can maintain current scholarship levels, but it will delay facility upgrades by two years.”
• For the athletic director: Link budget scenarios to competitive outcomes. “If we reallocate travel savings, we can fund a nutrition program that improves athlete recovery times.”
• For the boards: Frame decisions in terms of sustainability and optics. “This adjustment preserves our debt capacity and aligns with best practices in higher education governance.”

When each stakeholder hears financial information through their strategic lens, they can act with greater confidence and alignment.

3. Use Dashboards to Predict, Not Just Display

A well-built dashboard shouldn’t just show you where you are. It should help you anticipate where you’re heading.

Proactive tips:

• Integrate forecasting tools (Power BI, Tableau or even Excel trendlines) to display projected balances under multiple scenarios.
• Create an “early warning” section for metrics trending outside thresholds, like declining unrestricted reserves or rising per-athlete costs.
• Use color coding or scenario sliders (best case/worst case/most likely) to encourage discussion, not passive review.

Dashboards become more valuable when they drive conversations about course correction, not just confirmation.

4. Tell the Financial Story with a Future Plotline

Every institution’s athletics program has a financial narrative. But great CFOs add the next chapter.

Proactive tips:

• Connect numbers to the strategic arc: “Our investment in NIL programs is paying off with improved retention, but we’ll need to plan for the associated cost curve two years out.”
• Quantify the financial impact of upcoming decisions (conference realignment, capital projects, personnel changes) using simple “if/then” language.
• Include a “momentum metric” as one data point that signals positive movement toward a goal (e.g., donor growth rate, golf course margin improvement).

This turns financial updates into progress reports on institutional strategy.

5. Keep it Concise, Consistent and Action-Oriented

Time is limited for athletic directors and presidents. The most effective CFOs use brevity to drive urgency.

Proactive tips:

• Summarize each briefing with three short bullets: what we’re seeing, why it matters and what we need to do.
• Include a one-line decision dashboard at the end of each report: upcoming approvals, funding choices or risk mitigations.
• Reinforce accountability by tracking which past recommendations leadership acted on and what outcomes resulted.

This transforms finance updates from routine reports into strategic briefings with momentum.

Bottom line: Numbers tell a story, but leaders act on narratives with direction. The CFO who can connect data to strategy, and history to future action becomes not just the financial steward, but the institution’s most trusted advisor in shaping what comes next.

Need help turning numbers into meaningful dialogue? James Moore’s Collegiate Athletics CPAs and consultants help athletics business officers communicate with confidence and drive results.

All content provided in this article is for informational purposes only. Matters discussed in this article are subject to change. For up-to-date information on this subject please contact a James Moore professional. James Moore will not be held responsible for any claim, loss, damage or inconvenience caused as a result of any information within these pages or any information accessed through this site.