Florida Buyer Ordered to Pay $24,000 After Breaching Exclusive Broker Agreement

A recent arbitration decision in Florida has clarified the financial stakes of breaching exclusive buyer broker agreements under rules implemented following the National Association of REALTORS’ commission lawsuit settlement. The case resulted in a $24,000 award to Echo Fine Properties after a buyer purchased a home through a different brokerage while under contract with the firm.

The Case

Jeff Lichtenstein, broker-owner of Echo Fine Properties, entered into an exclusive buyer broker agreement with a client. Under the terms of the agreement, the buyer was contractually obligated to work exclusively with Echo Fine Properties during the search and purchase process.

The buyer later purchased a property with the assistance of another brokerage, breaching the exclusive agreement. Echo Fine Properties pursued arbitration to enforce the contract and recover the commission that would have been earned had the buyer honored the agreement.

The arbitration panel awarded Echo Fine Properties $24,000, affirming that the buyer’s actions constituted a breach of contract and that the brokerage was entitled to the agreed-upon compensation.

Why This Matters

Since NAR implemented mandatory buyer broker agreements as part of its commission lawsuit settlement, real estate professionals have questioned how these agreements would be enforced. The Florida case provides one of the first clear examples of how arbitration can be used to hold buyers accountable when they breach exclusive agreements.

Prior to the settlement, buyer representation agreements were not always required or consistently enforced. The new rules mandate written agreements before agents can show homes to buyers, making the contracts more formal and enforceable. This case demonstrates that buyers who sign exclusive agreements and then work with other agents may face significant financial consequences.

Implications for Buyers and Brokerages

For buyers, the case underscores the importance of understanding the terms of any agreement before signing. Exclusive buyer broker agreements are legally binding contracts, and breaching them can result in financial liability even if the buyer never closes on a property with the original brokerage.

For brokerages, the case confirms that exclusive agreements are enforceable through arbitration. Firms that invest time and resources in representing buyers have legal recourse if those buyers breach their agreements. However, pursuing arbitration involves costs and time, so brokerages must weigh whether enforcement is practical in each situation.

What Florida Real Estate Professionals Should Know

Florida’s real estate market has seen significant growth in recent years, and the state’s buyers and sellers are now navigating the new landscape created by the NAR settlement. Exclusive buyer broker agreements are now standard practice, and both buyers and agents need to understand their obligations.

Buyers should ask questions before signing agreements. How long does the agreement last? Can it be terminated early? What happens if the buyer wants to work with a different agent? Clear communication at the start of the relationship can prevent disputes later.

Agents and brokerages should ensure their agreements are clear, enforceable, and include terms that outline remedies for breach. Documentation is critical. If a dispute arises, having a well-drafted agreement and records of the services provided will strengthen the brokerage’s position in arbitration.

Looking Ahead

The arbitration decision in the Echo Fine Properties case is likely to influence how similar disputes are handled in the future. As more buyers and agents adjust to the new agreement requirements, additional cases may arise. Brokerages may become more proactive in enforcing agreements, and buyers may become more cautious about the contracts they sign.

For Florida real estate professionals, the takeaway is clear: exclusive buyer broker agreements are enforceable, and breaches can result in significant financial liability.

Real Estate Advisory and Accounting Support

Navigating the legal and financial aspects of real estate transactions requires attention to detail and an understanding of evolving industry practices. Whether you’re managing a brokerage, overseeing property transactions, or advising clients, our team can help you address the complexities of contract enforcement, commission structures, and business operations.

At James Moore, we work with real estate professionals across Florida to provide accounting, tax, and advisory services tailored to the industry. From business structuring to financial reporting, we help clients build sustainable practices that protect their interests and support growth.

Connect with our real estate team to discuss how we can support your business.

All content provided in this article is for informational purposes only. Matters discussed in this article are subject to change. For up-to-date information on this subject please contact a James Moore professional. James Moore will not be held responsible for any claim, loss, damage or inconvenience caused as a result of any information within these pages or any information accessed through this site.