Insurance Costs Lead Canadian Homeowners to Sell Florida Properties

Canadian snowbirds are increasingly selling their Florida properties as insurance costs have become a major financial burden. What once was a manageable expense has grown significantly, altering homeownership plans for many Canadians with Florida real estate.

This represents a notable trend in Florida’s property market. For years, Canadians have purchased homes in Florida, seeking warmer weather during the winter months. Now, many find themselves reconsidering these investments due to unexpected cost increases.

Understanding the Insurance Situation

The main issue comes from Florida’s unstable property insurance marketplace. Some Canadian homeowners report their annual premiums increasing from a few thousand dollars to approximately $16,000 yearly. This substantial increase affects properties throughout the state, not just those in coastal areas.

Several factors contribute to these insurance challenges:

• Underwriting losses for insurance companies
• Insurance company exits from the Florida market
• Higher claims following hurricanes
• Increased reinsurance costs
• Disputes over insurance claims

Many property owners now rely on Citizens Property Insurance Corp., the state-run insurer of last resort. However, Citizens has also implemented rate increases to maintain stability, providing limited relief for property owners.

Financial Challenges for Canadian Owners

Canadian owners face multiple financial pressures beyond just insurance increases:

• Currency exchange challenges with the Canadian dollar at approximately US$0.69
• Higher property taxes and maintenance fees
• Costs for properties they occupy seasonally

These combined factors have changed the financial equation for many owners, especially retirees with fixed incomes. 

Market Impact and Real Estate Changes

Real estate agents have noted that insurance rates have become a major factor in the growing number of Canadian sellers. The combination of rising insurance premiums, property taxes, and maintenance fees has reached a tipping point for many property owners.

Even homeowners who have not made insurance claims are seeing their insurance bills triple or quadruple. For many retirees who purchased properties when insurance costs were modest, the current premiums have become unsustainable.

Florida’s Insurance Market Conditions

The insurance situation has been developing over several years. Industry reports show that private insurers in Florida have faced consecutive years of underwriting losses, forcing some into insolvency and pushing more homeowners toward the state-run insurer.

Citizens Property Insurance Corp. has seen policy numbers surge, prompting regulators to approve rate increases to help stabilize the program. These market dynamics have transformed predictable annual expenses into financial burdens for many property owners.

Considerations for Property Owners

For those considering Florida property ownership, understanding the full cost implications has become increasingly important. The insurance situation adds a significant variable to the traditional calculation of property investment returns.

Current property owners may benefit from exploring all available insurance options and understanding how market changes might affect their long-term ownership costs. Florida remains an attractive location, but the financial equation has changed substantially.

Explore Property Ownership Decisions

Looking to optimize your real estate investments and tax strategy?

Our advisors help clients structure deals, manage cash flow, and plan confidently for the future. Connect with our real estate team.

All content provided in this article is for informational purposes only. Matters discussed in this article are subject to change. For up-to-date information on this subject please contact a James Moore professional. James Moore will not be held responsible for any claim, loss, damage or inconvenience caused as a result of any information within these pages or any information accessed through this site.