Florida Rental Market Shifts: What Southwest Florida’s Apartment Surplus Means for Investors

The Southwest Florida rental market is experiencing significant changes that real estate investors and property owners should understand. Collier County has seen a 275% year-over-year increase in new apartment units in 2025, positioning it as the fastest-growing metro for multifamily development in the nation, according to recent research.

This growth in supply is affecting the regional market. Rent prices have dropped substantially, with Collier County seeing approximately 10% decreases from 2023 to the present day, while Lee County has experienced steeper declines of nearly 15%. According to Apartment List, the median two-bedroom apartment price in Collier County has fallen from $1,740 in 2023 to $1,574 currently.

The “Accidental Landlords” Phenomenon

A notable trend in this shifting market is what industry analysts have termed “accidental landlords” – property owners who initially attempted to sell their homes but, faced with a sluggish sales market, switched to renting their properties instead.

This situation comes as Southwest Florida’s for-sale housing market continues to face challenges. As Florida Gulf Coast University’s economic report noted last month, the region has experienced an 8% year-over-year drop in single-family home sales and a 31% decrease in condo sales. Overall, median housing prices have declined by 10%.

The challenges for these reluctant landlords are made worse by misaligned pricing expectations. 

Financial Implications for Real Estate Investors

For real estate investors and property owners in Southwest Florida, these market conditions present both challenges and potential opportunities. The growing supply-demand imbalance means many landlords are offering incentives to attract tenants.

This competitive environment has led to increased tenant mobility, particularly in Lee County. The share of renters who move very frequently in Lee County has increased over the past five years, ranking it fifth-highest nationally for mobility rates. Nearly half of Lee County renters now change addresses every two years. These rapid tenant turnover rates can significantly impact a property’s financial performance. 

Strategic Approaches in a Challenging Market

For property owners and investors navigating this market, several strategic considerations come into play:

1. Realistic pricing strategies: Current market pricing continues to trend downward. Property owners who plan to reintroduce their homes to the market need to align with what buyers are actually willing to pay, or they may struggle to sell in the current market conditions.
2. Property tax assessments: As property values change, it may be worthwhile to review them. In Florida, property tax assessments can be appealed if market evidence suggests the assessed value exceeds market value.
3. Expense management: In a market with declining rental rates, expense management becomes increasingly important for maintaining acceptable returns on investment.
4. Strategic renovations: Targeted improvements that enhance competitive positioning without requiring significant rent increases may help maintain occupancy in a tenant-friendly market.

Southwest Florida’s Market Outlook

The current rental and housing market conditions in Southwest Florida represent a significant shift from the COVID-era boom. 

Looking ahead, the traditional seasonal patterns of the Southwest Florida market may provide some relief. Historically, housing inventory peaks in spring before declining through summer and early fall, then begins climbing again in October as snowbird season approaches. However, given current market dynamics, the impact of this seasonal pattern may be less pronounced compared to previous years.

Make Informed Real Estate Decisions

Looking to optimize your real estate investments and tax strategy?

Our advisors help clients structure deals, manage cash flow, and plan confidently for the future. Connect with our real estate team.

All content provided in this article is for informational purposes only. Matters discussed in this article are subject to change. For up-to-date information on this subject please contact a James Moore professional. James Moore will not be held responsible for any claim, loss, damage or inconvenience caused as a result of any information within these pages or any information accessed through this site.