Why Manufacturing Leaders Make Bad Pricing Decisions (And How to Fix It)

A manufacturing company went months charging the wrong price for its products. The result: a six-figure loss that went straight to the bottom line. The problem was not a lack of effort or intention. It was bad cost data driving bad manufacturing pricing decisions.

During a recent interview, Mike Sibley, partner at James Moore and a manufacturing CPA, shared insights on the real cost of pricing mistakes and why so many manufacturers keep making them. The discussion highlighted how a disconnect between internal reports and actual financial data can quietly drain profitability long before anyone notices.

The Gap Between What You Think Your Margins Are and What They Actually Are

One of the first things Sibley checks when working with a new client is margin data. He asks leaders what their margins look like by product, then compares their internal reports against the financial statements.

“I’ve got a margin report right here by product and it shows X. Well, I’ll have the financials and they’ll show Y and have very big differences,” Sibley explained. “That’s an early warning sign that they don’t actually know what their margins are.”

When those two numbers do not match, it signals deeper problems. Pricing may be off. Efficiency issues may be hiding in the numbers. And because financial statements can be hard to read, many leaders do not even realize the disconnect is there.

What Happens When You Wait Too Long to Act

Sibley was direct about the real cost of sitting on bad pricing data. He described a client who misunderstood their costing, made a bad pricing decision as a result, and then operated at the wrong price for months.

“They lost six figures of actual dollars and it would have just gone straight to the bottom line,” he said. “So the cost can be very significant.”

Pricing is not the only area where delayed action is expensive. Sibley also pointed to inventory as a hidden cost center. Carrying costs on excess inventory run between 20 and 30 percent. For a manufacturer sitting on too much stock, that percentage applied to the dollar value of that inventory can be a substantial loss, one that often goes unexamined.

Why Leaders Get Stuck on Pricing

According to Sibley, one of the most common places leaders lose momentum is on pricing decisions. They know something may need to change, but they do not trust the underlying data enough to act with confidence.

“They get stuck on do I do a price increase? Well maybe if I do a small one,” he said. The hesitation comes from a lack of reliable cost information, which creates a cycle where leaders avoid the very decisions that could improve profitability.

This is part of a broader pattern Sibley sees across manufacturing businesses: leaders making assumptions instead of digging into the numbers. “I think the first mistake is people making assumptions,” he said. “They assume this is what’s happening.” Without the right data to confirm or challenge those assumptions, businesses repeat the same patterns and expect different results.

How to Get Your Numbers Right

Sibley’s approach goes beyond fixing the accounting. When he starts working with a client, he moves quickly from financial statements to operations, looking for where the real problems originate.

“I thought you were just going to hang out in the accounting department the whole time, but you’re hanging out on the plant floor in operations more than anything else,” one client told him. That operational view is where Sibley finds the root causes of financial problems, including the cost allocation issues that lead to bad pricing.

A few practical steps manufacturers can take:

Reconcile your margin reports with your financials. If the numbers do not match, find out why before making any pricing decisions.

Understand your true cost structure. Product-level margin data is only useful if the underlying cost allocation is accurate. Errors in labor rates, overhead allocation, or material costs will flow through to your pricing models.

Review your KPIs with a critical eye. Sibley recommends going back to the metrics you are already tracking and asking whether they are tied to actual financial outcomes. “Am I actually using them? Is this helping me make decisions or not?” If the answer is no, it may be time to rethink what you are measuring.

Do not let uncertainty become inaction. Waiting for perfect data before adjusting pricing is a costly form of paralysis. Sibley recommends setting measurement points early so you can identify when something is not working and course-correct quickly.

The Real Price of Ignoring the Problem

Manufacturing pricing decisions that are based on inaccurate cost data do not just affect one product or one quarter. They compound over time, eroding margins, distorting planning, and making it harder to invest with confidence. The good news is that the fix usually starts with a closer look at the numbers you already have.

Watch the interview with Mike Sibley for more on how to identify financial blind spots, what questions strong leaders ask regularly and why connecting operations with finance is one of the highest-value moves a manufacturer can make.

Watch the episode here.

All content provided in this article is for informational purposes only. Matters discussed in this article are subject to change. For up-to-date information on this subject please contact a James Moore professional. James Moore will not be held responsible for any claim, loss, damage or inconvenience caused as a result of any information within these pages or any information accessed through this site.